In the world of agile project management, Planning Poker has become an essential tool for helping teams estimate the effort and complexity of tasks. This collaborative estimation technique is widely used in Scrum and other agile frameworks to ensure that teams stay aligned on project goals and timelines. If you’re looking to enhance your team’s planning process and foster better communication, Planning Poker is a valuable technique to integrate into your workflow.
In this guide, we will explain what Planning Poker is, how to play, its benefits, and how it can improve your team’s productivity and efficiency.
What is Planning Poker?
Planning Poker is a consensus-based technique used to estimate the effort or relative size of tasks in an agile project. It involves the entire team in providing estimates for each user story or task by selecting cards that represent their perceived effort or complexity. The idea is to have team members estimate tasks without influence from others, helping to uncover any discrepancies in understanding, and ensuring that each person has an opportunity to contribute.
The cards used in Planning Poker typically feature a Fibonacci sequence, with numbers like 1, 2, 3, 5, 8, 13, 21, and so on. This sequence is designed to reflect the increasing uncertainty as tasks become more complex, making it easier for teams to focus on relative estimates rather than getting bogged down in precise numbers.
How Does Planning Poker Work?
Here’s a step-by-step breakdown of how Planning Poker works:
1. Prepare the User Stories
Before the Planning Poker session, the Product Owner or Scrum Master prepares a list of user stories or tasks that need to be estimated. These stories should be well-defined, with clear acceptance criteria, so that the team can provide accurate estimates.
2. Explain the Story
The team gathers to discuss each user story. The Product Owner or Scrum Master provides any necessary context and answers any questions the team might have. It’s important that everyone has a shared understanding of the user story before moving forward.
3. Choose Cards
Each team member has a set of Planning Poker cards, typically with numbers from the Fibonacci sequence. These numbers represent the effort they believe the user story will require in terms of time or complexity. The cards allow for anonymous input from each person, preventing bias and influence from louder voices in the room.
4. Place Cards Simultaneously
After discussing the user story, each team member privately selects a card representing their estimate of the story’s complexity. Once everyone has made their selection, all the cards are revealed at the same time.
5. Discuss Discrepancies
If there’s a large difference between estimates, the team engages in a discussion. Typically, the members with the highest and lowest estimates explain their reasoning, which helps to uncover misunderstandings or different perspectives. The goal is to converge on a shared understanding of the task’s complexity.
6. Revote if Needed
After the discussion, the team may vote again, considering the insights shared during the discussion. This process repeats until the team reaches a consensus or the estimates converge to a small range.
7. Finalize the Estimate
Once the team has agreed on an estimate, the Product Owner or Scrum Master records it. This estimation is used in the backlog refinement process to prioritize tasks and make realistic sprint plans.
Benefits of Using Planning Poker
Planning Poker isn’t just a fun activity—it’s a powerful tool for agile teams. Here’s how it can benefit your team and project:
1. Encourages Collaboration
One of the main advantages of Planning Poker is that it involves the entire team in the estimation process. Each team member brings their unique perspective, which helps create a more accurate estimate. The discussions that follow the card reveal often uncover hidden risks, dependencies, or potential roadblocks that might not have been considered otherwise.
2. Promotes Shared Understanding
Because everyone in the team contributes to the estimate, Planning Poker ensures that everyone has a shared understanding of the task. This is critical in an agile environment, where collaboration and communication are key to success.
3. Prevents Groupthink
In many traditional planning meetings, louder or more senior voices can dominate the discussion, leading to biased estimates. Planning Poker counters this by having everyone make their estimates independently before revealing them. This helps prevent groupthink and encourages diverse opinions, leading to more accurate estimates.
4. Increases Accuracy
By involving multiple perspectives and allowing for discussion and clarification, Planning Poker helps teams arrive at more accurate estimates. It is particularly useful for estimating tasks that are ambiguous or complex, as the collective input helps cover a broader range of considerations.
5. Enhances Team Engagement
Planning Poker is more engaging than traditional estimation methods. The interactive nature of the game makes it fun and keeps team members focused and actively involved throughout the process. This can be particularly beneficial for remote teams, where keeping engagement levels high during meetings can be a challenge.
6. Improves Sprint Planning
With accurate estimates from the Planning Poker session, Scrum Masters and Product Owners can prioritize tasks more effectively. The estimates help inform sprint planning, ensuring that teams don’t overcommit or set unrealistic expectations. This leads to smoother, more predictable sprint cycles.
Common Challenges and How to Overcome Them
While Planning Poker is a great tool, like any methodology, it has some challenges. Here are a few common issues and how to handle them:
1. Disagreements on Estimates
Sometimes, team members may strongly disagree on an estimate. This can be frustrating, but it’s an opportunity to dive deeper into the task and explore different viewpoints. Encourage open communication, and make sure everyone feels comfortable expressing their concerns.
2. Estimates Are Too Inconsistent
If your estimates are highly inconsistent, it could be a sign that the user stories aren’t well-defined or that the team lacks understanding of the task. Take the time to refine the stories and ensure everyone has a clear understanding before estimating.
3. Influence of Strong Personalities
In some teams, dominant voices can influence the estimates of others. To mitigate this, consider anonymous voting, where team members submit their estimates privately through an online tool. This removes the influence of louder voices and allows for a more accurate reflection of each individual’s perspective.
Tips for Running a Successful Planning Poker Session
To make your Planning Poker sessions more effective, consider these tips:
-
Prepare in Advance: Ensure that all user stories are well-defined and have clear acceptance criteria before the session begins. This will help your team make more accurate estimates.
-
Keep It Short and Focused: A Planning Poker session should be focused on estimating tasks, not solving problems. Keep discussions concise, and ensure that the session doesn’t drag on unnecessarily.
-
Use Online Tools for Remote Teams: If your team is working remotely, there are several online tools available to run Planning Poker sessions, such as PlanningPoker.com or ScrumPoker. These tools allow for anonymous voting and real-time collaboration.
-
Review the Process Regularly: Over time, your team may become more experienced in estimating tasks. Periodically review the Planning Poker process to see if adjustments are needed to improve accuracy or efficiency.
Final Thoughts
Planning Poker is an essential technique for agile teams looking to improve their estimation process and foster better collaboration. By involving the entire team in the estimation process, encouraging discussion, and promoting a shared understanding, Planning Poker helps teams make more accurate predictions, avoid overcommitment, and plan sprints more effectively.
If you haven’t yet integrated Planning Poker into your agile workflow, now is the perfect time to start. With a little practice, your team will be able to make faster, more informed decisions, leading to smoother sprints and more successful project outcomes.
Leave a Reply